“If no one’s upset by what you’re saying, you’re probably not pushing hard enough.” — Rework by Jason Fried of 37signals
In the midst of my current redesign (and about fifty tossed ideas later) I came across the above quote which I engraved in my mind for the remainder of my redesign efforts. I used it not as a tool to make excuses for a potential bad design and negative reaction, but a stepping stone to break away from normalities and try something different and unfamiliar.
I’ve been truly grateful for the success of the Design Cubicle. Existing among one of the more popular traffic-driven design blogs on the internet, I did not want to have that same “big blog” feel (you might even notice I eliminated the sidebar ads). I never set out for those goals and did not want to give off that impression. I started The Design Cubicle to connect with other designers and those in need of design services. I wanted to share my passion and experiences. I also didn’t want to play it safe (in terms of the redesign direction) in fear of rejection. Personal discoveries and break-throughs will never be unearthed by playing it safe. Heck, even new trends cannot be set without at least one person taking a chance. Instead I wanted my own personal voice to be heard and seen — something my first design did not do well with.
As a web designer, when looking for inspiration I tend to look offline for ideas that will usher a direction. Something as simple as a book cover’s color palette, a typeface used in an old bus station, a texture or pattern from old architecture, and so on. Inspiration is everywhere, just look around you.
Even though I keep an inspiration collection in Little Snapper of online / web inspiration I seldom open this up when starting a new project; although I might come back to it once the project is underway and direction is established. The reasoning is to keep myself from repeating. Many times inspiration can indirectly lead to repeating and playing it safe. Sure playing it safe will always “work”, however, if you are not pushing boundaries because you are afraid of what people will say then you are not exploring and growing. You never know when that silly idea will turn into the next big trend.
Some of my favorite web designs are ones that I first initially said, “Wow, thats different…. not quite sure if I like it,” only to come back a few weeks later and absolutely fall in love with it. Once the initial shock of it looking “different” wore off I was able to dive into it and pull apart the elements that make it unique, engaging and beautiful. A month or so later we start seeing other websites germinating like weeds in the spring time following similar directions and techniques. Is it because the unfamiliar direction was approved by at least one other person? Probably so. Is it because you possibly had a similar thought a few months prior to seeing the “different” website but feared being rejected by some? Possibly. Either way, we should never let fear of rejection get in the way of trying something new. If no one is disagreeing what we are doing then we are probably being boring. It’s like little boys learned about the girls as they grow up: girls love the “bad boys.” But why? Because they are unpredictable and never boring. Treat your next web design as a new relationship. Impress him or her with your unpredictability and explore different options. There is always more than one way to solve a problem. Passing through solution A will help you discover a better solution in B.
A while back I read an article by @MikeKus talking about the direction for Carsonified’s website. After endless revisions, his final inspiration was discovered while jogging past a store sign that was hanging from a window. Carsonified’s website was one of which I said “not quite sure if I like this” and now, it is now one of my favorite websites. My first reactions were most likely a result of it looking unlike the rest. It was a bit daring and unorthodox, but this is what makes it truly beautiful and unique. A design that sets itself apart and will be remember as Carsonified’s. You could view that site from a hundred feet away and only glance at it for a second before knowing which site it is. How many websites can you say that about?
As not only designers, but as people in general, throughout our entire life we try so hard to gain acceptance by our peers, often forgetting what our own voice sounds like. Next time you design a website or your own portfolio think about the 37signals quote and push boundaries in light of showing the world your unique perspective. Step away from the online inspiration galleries and into the beautifully crafted world around you. Forget what people tell or think about you and go with your intuition.
The above article was not only to reach out but written for myself as well. We have all fallen guilty of this at one point in our careers. Even if living on the bold side of things isn’t for you, try at least one thing different in your next work and build around that idea. Without pushing boundaries the world around us remains stagnant and lifeless.
That’s a beautiful post. Something I just found out that was very encourage to me is that Donald Trump filed for bankruptcy 6 times. Reminds me that if it doesn’t hurt then it’s not real.
Not a huge fan of the UX for the new Design Cubicle, but overall, very beautiful!
Brian, you’ve outdone yourself here. Great post, amazing new design! One of the most difficult things to do in any field, and especially one like design, is to stand out from the crowd in an effective way. I think you’ve done that here brilliantly. I think the risk you took paid off big time. Great work!
@Scott, Thank you, and yes you are spot on with that statement. Any suggestions with the UX by your statement? Things you find confusing?
Brian, I’m digging the new digs :) I know that god is in the details, and I’m noticing the little touches that you’ve put into this redesign. The comment thread read “There are 2 comments, you will be the 3rd.” I eat that stuff up.
I’ll be coasting off your comments when I design my portfolio/blog site. I’ve had this same desire to make something different than what I’ve seen, which takes courage because it’s so easy/desirable to copy the amazing trends set by other designers.
Kudos.
Great job on the redesign Brian. The typography is beautifully elegant and your attention to detail makes all the difference. Just one observation regarding the ux: the fact that the navigation for the articles (the page numbers) is under the article, in my opinion, makes it a bit more difficult for the average user to get where they want to get fast.
Nice article Brian.
I appreciate anybody who takes an individual stance.
I like the new design but I think the narrow column is a bit clumsy on today’s high resolution screens. How does the website look on your 27″ iMac? Isn’it too thin?
I know you avoided editing 200+ posts but I’d like to see websites making use of the new dpi density and 16:9 format (not talking about horizontal sites).
On the technical side, since you show full posts on the homepage, how do you deal with duplicate content?
@Andrea,
Thanks for the kind words. Well actually, the width is 960 wide (from the comments to the Records side bar), but I wanted to place emphasis on the content area and still allow for a comfortable reading level for the width of the text area. On the iPad and iPhone the reading areas looks great and fills it up perfect, while on the 27″ iMac, sure it looks a bit strange, but quite honestly when I first got my 27″ iMac I think every website looked strange. As far as full posts on the home page… not really sure what you mean when you say “deal with duplicate content.” Do you mind clarifying? Thanks!
Great post Brian.
And though I agree with you, people usually have to learn the hard way before “understanding” something like this. Sure its easy to say I’ll do it different next time, but until I’ve done something the same way over and over, I won’t understand its true “value”.
Because its not about just standing out from the crowd (though thats part of it), its also about growing as a person and as a professional. Until you’ve got both ingredients, its hard to repeat success.
Thanks for sharing this piece of wisdom Brian.
@Brian
My initial reaction was “Where’s all the other blog posts?” I was confused as to where one — mostly lengthy — post ended and the next begain. Perhaps using excerpts may help.
I do quite enjoy the concept behind the notebook. Genius!
@Scott, I understand now. Within the two years of my site going the excerpt route I came to realize that most would just visit the site for the latest article and then leave. Those that visited other articles came directly from search engines and visited a particular post and the others came by searching topics (which I linked to at the top and on the bottom footer. Also you can search the Records archive to see them in excerpt format as well. A bit of analytical decision making on my behalf. Glad you enjoy the Notebook. Hope others do as well!
@Brian,
thanks for the explanation.
About the duplicate content I meant your homepage shows full posts but each post also has its own single page, available when you click on a title. This way each post is present twice on the blog and from an SEO standpoint duplicate content should be avoided because Google penalizes you.
I’m not so sure it’s a problem, though, as I’m not up to date with SEO. I’m sure the talented developers you worked with made the right choices, in fact TDC is more popular than ever.
Like Scott I am also having trouble finding the other articles. The topic list, being in the footer, is not exactly easy to find and the monthly archive is for me boring to browse.
Please see this as an obsevation, not a critique. I think most people will have trouble finding your content this way. We’re very susceptible to excerpts and thumbnails (they’re teasers) and there aren’t any here.
@Ankit: Thank you. Glad you enjoyed the read. After my redesign went live and also during its development showing off teasers on Dribbble I kept seeing the response from the color palette, many of which saying that they love it, but would be scared to try something similar. This went out to all those folks… don’t be afraid and go for it! :)
@Andrea:
Thanks for clarifying. Although it’s not actual duplicating. Instead its showing or not showing the comments. To comment or view comments you can either click the title link or click on the Comments flap. Some don’t like to be bothered with comments while others do. Even though my article introducing the new design yesterday posted an astonishing 182 comments (thank you all so much!) the article itself had close to 20,000 visits. I’d rather please 19,818 than 182 :)
As far as finding more articles, please see me comment to Scott. I’ll do some more testing to see overall reactions, although its hard to please everyone. I do however always take into consideration everyones feedback and greatly appreciate it all. Thank you for taking the time to share with me.
@Brian
Good thing you run this site and not me. That’s some genius analysis. Thanks for the update!
Brian, I think you mean “Jason Fried of 37signals”. Unless of course he has a sibling that secretly helped him write that line :)
And the new site is beautiful congrats!
Great post and great work on the redesign. I often checked your ‘dribbble’ just to glimpse the details in anticipation of the launch.
It’s really easy to get pulled into the so called ‘web trends’ and totally lose yourself to what you perceive your design is expected to look like.
The idea of being inspired more and more by the things around you should make us all unique designers with an even more interesting story to tell. I’m writing from the Caribbean, a place full of colour and character. Unfortunately I haven’t be tapping into that massive pool of inspiration, instead I find myself in a constant fight to give in to trends in the hope of having my portfolio site featured on a css gallery.
This post is a really good reminder to go with my gut and pull from what’s around me.
This is an amazing article, as a designer in a corporate environment this is an extremely hard point to get across. Different does not equal bad, it can be a very positive step.
Brian:
Agree with the other commentors on “there are 17 comments, you will be the 18th” (nice subtle persuasion there to add my voice).
Starting as children we want to fit in and be accepted by everyone even though instinctively I believe we all realize it’s not feasible.
Eventually we need to realize that we can’t possibly be everything to everyone. :-)
Fantastic job on the thought provoking post.
Just a quick note that I love the site. Very understated but it’s very strong. Standing out in a sea of design blogs is tough to do but great content packaged right makes all the difference. Consider your site bookmarked.
Cheers,
Chris
@adoodleblog
Impressive and different!
The issue I am facing is when I click on Topics (at top) it takes me to the bottom of the page but since I have 24″mac, I’ve to look for the topics which are way down under the About section. Otherwise its very nice.
awesome. i couldn’t agree more. i’m saving this article in my own inspiration folder.
This is a truly inspiring post. I’ve found myself torn between wanting to be accepted and finding that conforming makes my voice less unique. You’re absolutely right and I find myself wanting to take a long hard look at my personal projects and rethink whether they’re personal enough. I know what I’ll be doing over my holiday weekend.
Beautiful redesign, btw.
Go get yourself a Wawa coffee, you deserve it :)
Great post, very inspiring. And Jason Fried owes you some commission! Just bought the book after reading and connecting with that quote you used.
Great post and I love the redesign. Most designers want their work to stand out in the crowd but tend to end up conforming to the trends in the industry.
We forget that trends start out by being different from the rest.
artsybee
A timely article for me. I’m not redesigning my site (yet), but I am working on a design for a new side project and I’ve been beating my head against the wall with it. Some days I like it, some days I feel like it’s all been done before or just doesn’t stand out. I need to turn off my inspirational feeds and wholly focus on what I want it to look like. I also want to push the boundaries and your words have encouraged me to keep on towards that goal.
Hey Brian!
Love the new design… Its simple and easy to use. And a very inspirational article.
I really liked the concept for the Notebook.
All the best!
I really like your new layout and colors, but that font face is killing me.
Steve,
Thanks for the kind words, however not sure what you mean when you say the font face is killing you. Do you mind being more specific? Thanks.
You’re writing is developing as well as your designs. Great work mate.
What I find most difficult when trying to push a boundary is to keep it actually looking good/right. I’ve found falling back to the old CARP acronym helpful.
- Is that little Twitter hover script freely available somewhere?
Brad,
Thank you! Glad both aspects appearing to be changing for the good. As for the Twitter hovercards they are available via @anywhere — which is Twitters new developer tools. Visit dev.twitter.com/anywhere and sign in with your Twitter account. The rest is self-explanatory.
Your work, your design, your passion. It’s in sticking to your own design and standing up for it, that other people really learn to appreciate and acknowledge what goes on in that specific design. Ultimately, that’s what makes you stand out and even more special right? Excellent and inspired writing! Thanks – Jarmaine
Brian, I’m sure this article would help lot of designers to be more confident about their own capabilities & design skills, to make great stuffs and push their boundaries.
It’s a great post.
ps : 20.000 readers for your last post, more than 180 comments… you must be very proud, you deserve it dude, really. Amazing.
Thank you so much for this post. Someone tweeted about it and I’m very glad to have found you. I have been pushing my own personal boundaries these days and your words touched me.
Normally, when I come across a website that I love, I will simply send out a tweet and move on with my day. In this case, I also needed to leave a comment (maybe it is the narcissist in me).
Brian, you have put your heart on the chopping block and I stand and applaud you for having the guts to do so. I know how difficult it is to step away from a comfort zone to explore an uncharted direction… to say that I am going to create something that speaks to me and hopefully other people will dig it. Well, you have a new “fan” in me.
Some may look your redesign and walk away wondering, “what is so special?” For those individuals, I would challenge them to hang around a while a gaze at the subtle details. You color palette alone was enough for me to want gaze at the majesty as a whole.
Enough of my praise. In all seriousness, this is a well executed redesign and many congratulations.
Great post Brian. I couldn’t agree more. I’m a beginner blogger, long time designer, and I just launched a redesign of my site as well. I really struggled with the issue of pushing the envelope. Mainly because I knew it was something I would have to sacrifice. Though I have web knowledge I don’t have the wherewithal to be adventurous. You and your crew have done a fantastic job with this redesign. There is a lot to learn from it. I would love your critical opinion if you ever get the opportunity to swing by my site @ squareinchdesign.com. My blog is mainly inspirational, but I have a lot of knowledge to drop so I might be making an informational venture.
Best of luck with the new site. I hope it’s bring loads of traffic and great connections.
I honestly love the whole thing. The only thing that irks me is the author comment with your picture. Not because you’re an ugly dude, but rather because it is kind of jarring when all other comments are aligned to the left edge.